The Oldest Bar in Wisconsin Disputed

Landmark 1850 Inn

Milwaukee, Wisconsin · Westward Expansion · Est. 1850 · Open today

Official Site ↗ Directions ↗
The Story

Since 1850

The Italianate building was constructed in the late 1840s as the New Cologne House, serving as a saloon, inn, and weighing station for farmers hauling produce between Racine and Milwaukee counties; it has anchored the corner near today's Mitchell International Airport ever since. Joe Halser III bought the tavern in 1983 and spent decades restoring it in late-19th-century saloon style, complete with a potbelly stove, vintage icebox, pressed-tin ceiling, and stained glass. Halser kept the bar open for 40 years, reportedly until the day before he died in 2022, after which the tavern went dark. Linda Garcia, who had worked at the inn in the 1990s, connected with Halser's sons in fall 2023 and reopened the bar on April 13, 2024, preserving its historic interior. As of 2026 it operates as a neighborhood tavern and live-music venue celebrating 175 years of tradition.

Local lore holds that Racine farmers who drank too long at the saloon after selling their produce in Milwaukee would fall asleep in their horse-drawn wagons on the way home — trusting the horses to know the route.
Verification & Evidence

How solid is the claim?

Disputed

Wisconsin’s oldest bar — the evidence

Landmark 1850 Inn in Milwaukee is our featured pick for the oldest bar in Wisconsin, with a claimed founding year of 1850. Well documented as Milwaukee's oldest bar (TMJ4, Urban Milwaukee, CBS58, OnMilwaukee), but the statewide 'oldest bar in Wisconsin' title rests largely on the Business Insider list: Red Circle Inn in Nashotah dates to 1848 (two years earlier), Monarch Public House claims the state's oldest continuously operating tavern, and the Landmark itself was closed from 2022 to April 2024 between owners, breaking strict continuity.

Claimed Founding
1850
Operating Status
Open today — Open as of mid-2026. The bar closed after longtime owner Joseph Halser III died in 2022, then reopened April 13, 2024 under new owner Linda Garcia (a former 1990s employee). It is actively hosting a 2026 summer concert series (Tuesdays, July 7 - September 30, 2026) and marketing its 175-year tradition. (An old Yelp listing from before the 2024 reopening still shows 'CLOSED'; the current listing is active.)
Verification
Disputed
Last Reviewed
July 2026

Competing Claims

Other Wisconsin establishments with a stake in the title:

1848
Red Circle Inn — Nashotah
Opened in 1848 as the Nashotah Inn and billed as Wisconsin's oldest supper club/restaurant; its 1848 founding predates the Landmark's 1850 date, though it operates as a supper club rather than a tavern.
1894
Monarch Public House — Fountain City
Claims to be the oldest continually serving tavern/pub in Wisconsin (building erected 1893-94 by the Odd Fellows) — a 'continuous operation' claim the Landmark can no longer match after its 2022-2024 closure.

Sources

Keep Driving

Next stops on the trail

Build This Into a Road Trip

From the Field Guide

Related reading